On Sunday, Mothers' Day, I went to visit a long-time family friend and former teacher. She is a retired special education teacher who has basically become a second mom to me (hence, the Mothers' Day visit). At one point during the visit, she showed me a gift she bought for her friend's three-year-old autistic daughter. The gift was a hat that read "Autism Awareness" and had interlocking puzzle pieces on it, similar to this one, but not exactly the same.
This led to a bit of an argument between us. I know Autism Speaks "supports the families" of autistic people much more than they support the autistic individuals, and I explained this to her. Her response to this was that the family needs the money to "deal with" the autistic child(ren). I'm paraphrasing her, except for the quoted phrase, which honestly bugged the hell out of me.
I'm not autistic, but I am a cripple. I can understand assisting the family, especially financially, only until the autistic individual or other PWD reaches an age that for others without disabilities would be considered "adulthood" or "maturity". During the argument, I suggested age sixteen, but that seems very random when every case is different. To explain it a bit, I suggested sixteen because that is when the average non-disabled teen would start driving, and when their parents would likely say "if you want to drive, get a job." A teen getting a job implies they have to be trusted with the money they earn. My friend's response to trusting a sixteen-year-old autistic individual with their own finances was essentially that these individuals may not be able to manage their money well enough, which may or may not be true depending on the individual. However, it took everything I had at this point to keep myself from screaming "THEN LET THEM FAIL!". To be clear, I don't want autistic people to fail at being independent, but you have to open up to the possibility of failure to give them a chance to be independent.
She argued that "some autistic people can't speak". Just because they are nonverbal doesn't mean they can't communicate. There's a huge difference there. I was surprised by the fact that a former special education teacher does not know about AAC devices and text-to-speech programs. In the past two years or so, I've seen stories about some very successful nonverbal autistics "finding communication". Carly Fleischmann has been featured in the news explaining how she's been able to express her thoughts clearly with the help of technology. I've also just finished watching Wretches & Jabberers which I will defer to their own website to summarize.
I'm 27, and I still live with my mom because I've been having trouble finding work partially due to my disability and partially due to my location and other factors. I have cerebral palsy and I've been diagnosed with osteoarthritis, and I don't currently receive any financial "benefits" Apart from college tuition assistance which went directly to the university and three months of Social Security Survivor's benefits after my father passed away when I was 18, I haven't received any financial help. When I have applied for federal or state government assistance, I've been denied with the exception of Medicaid, but that's not directly financial. The survivor's benefit totaled about $4000, and my mother took two-thirds of it from me. I wasn't the best at saving what remained in my hands, but there are reasons for this. First, I was 18 years old and was just handed $1300. Secondly, I would be going away to college soon and would be "free" for the first time in my life, and that was cause for celebration for me. I failed, just as I say young autistic adults should have the opportunity to do. This amount of money wasn't enough for me to jump and decide to live on my own, but it wasn't exactly pocket change either. That was a lesson for me, and the only one I needed. I failed, but I was allowed to fail at a young enough age where I had a safety net. If you don't trust somebody with money until they're 30, they might fail and end up living on the street. If I would receive any sort of financial "benefit" in the future, I need it to be in my name and FOR ME. I say that because there is a constant air of "you owe me for taking care of you" around me. If that money went to my mother to "help the family", as Autism Speaks does, it would perpetuate the situation I'm in physically and mentally, as well as perpetuating the idea that I will never be an adult because I don't have my own money.
You cannot teach the value of a dollar at any age by handing someone a $5 bill and saying "spend it wisely". $5 won't get you much of anything today. The only way to teach somebody how to be independent with money is to put all the money in their hands, not to give the money to the family to help them "deal with" their "child". I realize that parents of children with any disability need assistance to support their child(ren), but it should never be up to the parents or up to a third-party organization to determine when a child isn't a child anymore. This is why the thought of owing my mother for "dealing with me" sickens me. I haven't had the resources to be independent yet, but when they come to me, they will come to ME, and that's the way it has to be. I've started to wonder whether almost everyone in any aspect of my life is just "dealing with me". A few people, including my girlfriend and a couple close friends have told me explicitly that they aren't just "dealing with me", but it seems everyone else is, and I need to become independent to break that cycle. Autistic people need that independence, too, and taking financial support away from me or any of them is counterproductive. If society would allow people with disabilities to be independent, maybe nobody would be "dealing with" us anymore and they can start respecting all of us as individuals.
"Before you criticize someone, you should walk a mile in their shoes. That way, when you criticize them, you're a mile away and you have their shoes."
Monday, May 13, 2013
Wednesday, May 1, 2013
Having Disabilities is a Full-Time Job
Apparently the fact that I have disabilities is enough to make the world believe I'm a magician. The words "disability" and "disappear" may begin with the same four letters, but that should be where the list of connections ends; unfortunately, it isn't nearly the end. People tell me all the time to hide my disabilities, but my cerebral palsy, vision impairment, osteoarthritis, and adjustment disorder are things that I cannot hide. If I try to hide them, and they "appear", I would undoubtedly have trouble explaining exactly what is happening to me in the heat of a moment like that. These same people also seem to think that "receiving" my bachelor's degree has made my options limitless. As a side note, I did more than "receive" my degree, I EARNED it, and even that may be an understatement; I had to fight for it. The assumption that I have no limits could not be further from the truth. They all forget, conveniently or not, that my disabilities are still with me and always will be. I can work through the adjustment disorder, but the others will never go away.
I wonder how long it will (or more likely won't) be before the next person wants me to make my disabilities disappear. At the same time, I wonder how long it will be before people realize that disabilities do not have off switches. I also wonder when people will ask me to act like a crippled old man again. If I apply for a job, I always hear "don't tell them about your disability" but if I apply for government assistance of any type, I get told to "play it up". It definitely does not work that way. If I would choose to hide my disabilities from a potential employer, I could get denied accommodations that I may desperately need. The other extreme is probably more detrimental to me. If I would "play up" my disabilities to the government to get what they call "benefits", I could possibly be arrested for either fraud or perjury. Nothing is worth putting a felony on my record. If I'm not willing to take a felony charge myself, you have no chance of getting me to do that for your benefit.
Maybe that would explain why things like Social Security are called "benefits", anybody in the applicant's life tries to benefit without doing anything. Yes, if they're employed, they pay into this system, but maybe that's why it's a benefit to them. To me, it would be a life changer, a shot at independence, and ironically, a shot at getting off that system and into the working world. I just happen to live in an area that has nothing to offer me. I need the means to move to find a job, but I need a job or financial assistance to get that. Government assistance is called assistance for a reason, and truthfully, assistance is what I need. My goal is to work a full-time job, but without an opportunity, that will never happen. Stay-at-home moms say that's a full-time job, and it is, as is being a college student. Having a disability is a full-time job too, but it's like slave labor, it's not volunteer work but it doesn't pay. I can already hear you saying "it doesn't pay? then what's the disability benefit?" Stop using the word "benefit", for one thing. It's not a benefit, it's a lifeline. Secondly, this is a 168 hour per week job without holidays. That's right, My disabilities don't clock out. My disabilities don't give me a day off, ever. If they don't give ME a day off, you damn sure don't get a day to tell me how I'm affected. You don't get to tell me when I'm normal, when I'm me, or when I'm a complete cripple. I'm the one that tells you, the government, or a potential employer what my limits are today, tomorrow, or any day until I'm dead. That's right, I said "limits". My options are not limitless, even with my degree in hand. My disabilities don't shift gears and become more or less severe when somebody wants them to, not even when I'm that somebody. They shift gears on their own, and there is no neutral. The only reverse involves me saying "I'm in too much pain" and backing up into my bed. Three of my four disabilities are incurable, and people acting like I can be cured overnight makes me incorrigible. Everybody in my life needs to know I have disabilities, and the only person who should be using these disabilities to judge me is...well....a judge, the social security appeals judge. I don't judge myself based on my disabilities and I'm the one who sets that example, or I would be setting the example if people actually followed it. It's such a struggle to get the critics to follow it. I've graduated college, I'm done being graded, but I'm not done with being disabled, and I'll never be done with that.
I don't have the benefit of tailoring the levels of my disabilities to fit the situation, and you don't either. If I don't have to address you as "your honor"...in the appeal hearing, you don't have the authority to judge how disabled I am. I'm not lazy, I have limits. Education doesn't make the limits disappear. The only things that can possibly make my disabilities easier for everyone to handle are proper accessibility and acceptance. Of course, it's most important that things are easier for me, or for any other person out there who has disabilities. Another aspect of acceptance is accepting that I'm the authority on my own life. Don't set expectations for me. I don't care to meet them, and I don't care if you're disappointed. All I'm out to do is live and enjoy my own life my way, and my way doesn't involve denying who I am. Being who I am doesn't involve being Supercripple or a poster child either. We are not here to make things easier for everyone else and we aren't asking for "too easy". All I'm asking for is accept me for who I am and keep the playing field level. Real acceptance is shown, not just spoken. I may not have control over accessibility issues. I will try to make people accept me for who I am, but I can only try so hard. I just hope one of those people who accepts me has a business behind them and can offer me the opportunity that I need. Of course, the ultimate goal is not just to get these opportunities and acceptance for myself, but to do that for everyone out there who has a disability. Having a disability is a full-time job, but it shouldn't keep me or anyone like me from getting a real full-time job and living a full life.
I wonder how long it will (or more likely won't) be before the next person wants me to make my disabilities disappear. At the same time, I wonder how long it will be before people realize that disabilities do not have off switches. I also wonder when people will ask me to act like a crippled old man again. If I apply for a job, I always hear "don't tell them about your disability" but if I apply for government assistance of any type, I get told to "play it up". It definitely does not work that way. If I would choose to hide my disabilities from a potential employer, I could get denied accommodations that I may desperately need. The other extreme is probably more detrimental to me. If I would "play up" my disabilities to the government to get what they call "benefits", I could possibly be arrested for either fraud or perjury. Nothing is worth putting a felony on my record. If I'm not willing to take a felony charge myself, you have no chance of getting me to do that for your benefit.
Maybe that would explain why things like Social Security are called "benefits", anybody in the applicant's life tries to benefit without doing anything. Yes, if they're employed, they pay into this system, but maybe that's why it's a benefit to them. To me, it would be a life changer, a shot at independence, and ironically, a shot at getting off that system and into the working world. I just happen to live in an area that has nothing to offer me. I need the means to move to find a job, but I need a job or financial assistance to get that. Government assistance is called assistance for a reason, and truthfully, assistance is what I need. My goal is to work a full-time job, but without an opportunity, that will never happen. Stay-at-home moms say that's a full-time job, and it is, as is being a college student. Having a disability is a full-time job too, but it's like slave labor, it's not volunteer work but it doesn't pay. I can already hear you saying "it doesn't pay? then what's the disability benefit?" Stop using the word "benefit", for one thing. It's not a benefit, it's a lifeline. Secondly, this is a 168 hour per week job without holidays. That's right, My disabilities don't clock out. My disabilities don't give me a day off, ever. If they don't give ME a day off, you damn sure don't get a day to tell me how I'm affected. You don't get to tell me when I'm normal, when I'm me, or when I'm a complete cripple. I'm the one that tells you, the government, or a potential employer what my limits are today, tomorrow, or any day until I'm dead. That's right, I said "limits". My options are not limitless, even with my degree in hand. My disabilities don't shift gears and become more or less severe when somebody wants them to, not even when I'm that somebody. They shift gears on their own, and there is no neutral. The only reverse involves me saying "I'm in too much pain" and backing up into my bed. Three of my four disabilities are incurable, and people acting like I can be cured overnight makes me incorrigible. Everybody in my life needs to know I have disabilities, and the only person who should be using these disabilities to judge me is...well....a judge, the social security appeals judge. I don't judge myself based on my disabilities and I'm the one who sets that example, or I would be setting the example if people actually followed it. It's such a struggle to get the critics to follow it. I've graduated college, I'm done being graded, but I'm not done with being disabled, and I'll never be done with that.
I don't have the benefit of tailoring the levels of my disabilities to fit the situation, and you don't either. If I don't have to address you as "your honor"...in the appeal hearing, you don't have the authority to judge how disabled I am. I'm not lazy, I have limits. Education doesn't make the limits disappear. The only things that can possibly make my disabilities easier for everyone to handle are proper accessibility and acceptance. Of course, it's most important that things are easier for me, or for any other person out there who has disabilities. Another aspect of acceptance is accepting that I'm the authority on my own life. Don't set expectations for me. I don't care to meet them, and I don't care if you're disappointed. All I'm out to do is live and enjoy my own life my way, and my way doesn't involve denying who I am. Being who I am doesn't involve being Supercripple or a poster child either. We are not here to make things easier for everyone else and we aren't asking for "too easy". All I'm asking for is accept me for who I am and keep the playing field level. Real acceptance is shown, not just spoken. I may not have control over accessibility issues. I will try to make people accept me for who I am, but I can only try so hard. I just hope one of those people who accepts me has a business behind them and can offer me the opportunity that I need. Of course, the ultimate goal is not just to get these opportunities and acceptance for myself, but to do that for everyone out there who has a disability. Having a disability is a full-time job, but it shouldn't keep me or anyone like me from getting a real full-time job and living a full life.
Thursday, April 11, 2013
If a tree falls in the forest...
...And no one is there to hear it, does it make a sound? This is a question that generations of people have asked, and there has never been a definitive answer. I'm not looking for the answer, I would rather update the question for the twenty-first century. If I share a post on Facebook, and nobody takes the time to read it, does my opinion matter?
Anybody with an Internet-connected computer, smartphone, or tablet can be a blogger. There could be half a billion bloggers just in the English-speaking world. Even Twitter is considered blogging, albeit "microblogging".
If Tumblr is your blogging site of choice, you will see a lot of posts pertaining to various facets of social justice. You'll see everything from race equality posts to feminist posts to disability equality and GLBTQ equality support and many more "hot button topics". The "issue" with Tumblr, for lack of a better way to say it, is that these posts are strewn between posts about TV shows and pictures that contain random quotes which people re-post either because they can relate or purely because they laughed at them. There are also too many "guilt trip" posts. We've all seen them, and we're all probably "going to hell" because of that one post we chose to ignore rather than reblog, or that one we chose not to share on Facebook. I'd rather just use my own judgment when I decide whether to like or share a post on either site. If I like it, I'll "like" it too. Because people subscribe to the false sentiments in posts like this, blogs and Facebook pages are filled with them, but then the posts that are intended to start legitimate discussions or spread a thought-provoking message are obscured.
If you'd rather write where your opinion can be taken more seriously (because it's not appearing between a post about Anime and a Futurama Fry meme image), you can come to a site like Blogger or Wordpress. The catch here is that these sites don't have the reach that Facebook, Tumblr and Twitter do. As of July 15, 2009, Facebook had 250 million users. In just over three years, that number quadrupled. In October, 2012, Facebook hit 1 billion users. Twitter has about half as many users as Facebook, and Tumblr only has about 170 million users. That site also says that Wordpress has 74 million blogs. Google chooses not to disclose how many Blogger users there are. I could find followers quickly on Twitter, but 140 characters does not serve the purpose. If I wanted to write this on Twitter, I would hit the character limit before I got halfway through the first paragraph. Ignoring the subject of this post, a tweet that hit the character limit would read "...And no one is there to hear it, does it make a sound? This is a question that generations of people have asked, and there has never been ". Even if I had 500 followers on Twitter, I'd have 500 people telling me that tweet is nonsensical and a waste of time.
My best bet is to finish writing this, share it on my Facebook page, and then just hope it doesn't get lost in random status updates and guilt trip posts. There is always the chance that the exact opposite would happen. Maybe I have caught someone's eye; maybe someone out there likes my ideas enough to take them further than the web. Just like running for office or getting a job, I would need to know the right people. I don't have many connections like that; if I'm lucky, I can use the theory of six degrees of separation and it reaches someone who has the means to help me take it to a wider audience. It would be nice to become famous because of a blog post, but fame would be just a bonus. I would rather see my thoughts have a positive effect on a community. I'm just one of over a billion people on Facebook, and I'm an even smaller drop in the bucket that is the whole of the world wide web. I can track how many people "like" or share a post after I link to it on Facebook, but maybe I made them feel guilty. Maybe they shared my post to add their counterpoint. Maybe you've had an epiphany while reading this but you've forgotten about it because I rambled.
I'm not specifically on a mission for fame, but on the other hand, I'm tired of being just a drop in the bucket. There has to be some middle ground somewhere. I want to be an activist, not just some guy with random ideas and a computer. I want people to see that this isn't just me telling people that the world owes me a better life. The world doesn't "owe" me, but I could use the help. That is why I write what I write. Maybe somebody will read it. Maybe they can help me, or maybe they are in the same situation or a very similar one. I need an opportunity, but I'm not the only one. Maybe this isn't the post that brings the publicity I'm looking for, but then again, maybe it will bring publicity to my future or past blog entries. All that being said, there's not much left to do but ask again, maybe a bit differently this time: if I share a post on Facebook, even if all my friends take the time to read it, does my opinion matter? I can only hope I'm making a twenty-first century "sound".
Anybody with an Internet-connected computer, smartphone, or tablet can be a blogger. There could be half a billion bloggers just in the English-speaking world. Even Twitter is considered blogging, albeit "microblogging".
If Tumblr is your blogging site of choice, you will see a lot of posts pertaining to various facets of social justice. You'll see everything from race equality posts to feminist posts to disability equality and GLBTQ equality support and many more "hot button topics". The "issue" with Tumblr, for lack of a better way to say it, is that these posts are strewn between posts about TV shows and pictures that contain random quotes which people re-post either because they can relate or purely because they laughed at them. There are also too many "guilt trip" posts. We've all seen them, and we're all probably "going to hell" because of that one post we chose to ignore rather than reblog, or that one we chose not to share on Facebook. I'd rather just use my own judgment when I decide whether to like or share a post on either site. If I like it, I'll "like" it too. Because people subscribe to the false sentiments in posts like this, blogs and Facebook pages are filled with them, but then the posts that are intended to start legitimate discussions or spread a thought-provoking message are obscured.
If you'd rather write where your opinion can be taken more seriously (because it's not appearing between a post about Anime and a Futurama Fry meme image), you can come to a site like Blogger or Wordpress. The catch here is that these sites don't have the reach that Facebook, Tumblr and Twitter do. As of July 15, 2009, Facebook had 250 million users. In just over three years, that number quadrupled. In October, 2012, Facebook hit 1 billion users. Twitter has about half as many users as Facebook, and Tumblr only has about 170 million users. That site also says that Wordpress has 74 million blogs. Google chooses not to disclose how many Blogger users there are. I could find followers quickly on Twitter, but 140 characters does not serve the purpose. If I wanted to write this on Twitter, I would hit the character limit before I got halfway through the first paragraph. Ignoring the subject of this post, a tweet that hit the character limit would read "...And no one is there to hear it, does it make a sound? This is a question that generations of people have asked, and there has never been ". Even if I had 500 followers on Twitter, I'd have 500 people telling me that tweet is nonsensical and a waste of time.
My best bet is to finish writing this, share it on my Facebook page, and then just hope it doesn't get lost in random status updates and guilt trip posts. There is always the chance that the exact opposite would happen. Maybe I have caught someone's eye; maybe someone out there likes my ideas enough to take them further than the web. Just like running for office or getting a job, I would need to know the right people. I don't have many connections like that; if I'm lucky, I can use the theory of six degrees of separation and it reaches someone who has the means to help me take it to a wider audience. It would be nice to become famous because of a blog post, but fame would be just a bonus. I would rather see my thoughts have a positive effect on a community. I'm just one of over a billion people on Facebook, and I'm an even smaller drop in the bucket that is the whole of the world wide web. I can track how many people "like" or share a post after I link to it on Facebook, but maybe I made them feel guilty. Maybe they shared my post to add their counterpoint. Maybe you've had an epiphany while reading this but you've forgotten about it because I rambled.
I'm not specifically on a mission for fame, but on the other hand, I'm tired of being just a drop in the bucket. There has to be some middle ground somewhere. I want to be an activist, not just some guy with random ideas and a computer. I want people to see that this isn't just me telling people that the world owes me a better life. The world doesn't "owe" me, but I could use the help. That is why I write what I write. Maybe somebody will read it. Maybe they can help me, or maybe they are in the same situation or a very similar one. I need an opportunity, but I'm not the only one. Maybe this isn't the post that brings the publicity I'm looking for, but then again, maybe it will bring publicity to my future or past blog entries. All that being said, there's not much left to do but ask again, maybe a bit differently this time: if I share a post on Facebook, even if all my friends take the time to read it, does my opinion matter? I can only hope I'm making a twenty-first century "sound".
Friday, March 1, 2013
Live Inexpensively or Die
Originally posted on April 7, 2012 by disabilityrightnow
by Clint Berger
Early news stories about George Hodgins’ murder stated the “views” of his mother about the services that were available to help George and people like him, or the alleged lack of them. That statement was later refuted. George Hodgins had been involved in at least one organization that provided him both the help he needed and social interaction in his community. His mother took this away from him, saying that she wanted to find something better for him, but she did not see this through. She instead decided to take his life and her own.
George was affiliated with the Morgan Autism Center in San Jose, California. He was there for schooling and to learn life skills. His mother pulled him out of this program, but did not actively pursue other opportunities for him as she said she would. A representative of the Center stated that they had services available for adults as well as for children. George would have been eligible for adult services at age 22. Instead of letting him continue working with the Morgan Autism Center, Elizabeth Hodgins had something else in mind. George would have learned to be more independent, and he could have made friends and become more active in his community. The opportunity for a full life was stolen from him, and then life itself was stolen as well.
Elizabeth Hodgins used a supposed lack of services for her son as “justification” for murder. To say that this is wrong is a gross understatement. Some of us legitimately do not have services available and we are still alive. Often, the “burden” of raising a disabled child is heavily financial. This is likely one of Elizabeth’s possible motives for George’s murder. We will never find out the true cause of his murder, but it is possible that the monetary costs of caring for George were a factor in her twisted thought process. We will never get the truth, nor will we know the truth of what happened to any of the others whose names were read at the vigils. Since the vigils, more of us have been murdered, and with each of these murders, we all wonder when our voices will be heard.
Money can be tight for families of people with disabilities, but it can be used to control and abuse us; this is a concept and a lifestyle that is very familiar to me. Every day of my life, I get constant reminders of how much it costs for everything from the electric bill to my student loans. I am not on any federal or state assistance, and I am unemployed. I have a caseworker assigned to me who is supposed to be providing services similar to those available to George, but my calls are not returned. My needs are not treated as needs, and I am told I live too far from public transportation to be able to use paratransit. I essentially have nothing available to me right now; and that is why it is so upsetting that someone would lie about their child’s potential to evoke sympathy for themselves. George was working with the Morgan Center, and there are no accounts that justify his mother’s assertion that he was not receiving proper support there.
George’s case brings so many questions for anyone with disabilities. The question at the top of this list is something to the effect of, “How long will they let me live before my life is taken?”, but this is not the only question we have. The next question we all ask ourselves is “how will I be independent?”. We all struggle to be as independent as possible, but many of the government and nonprofit agencies that are established to help people with disabilities are actually geared toward helping their families instead. They are supposed to be helping us, but even they overlook us. George needed help. He needed to remove himself from the family that was supposed to be helping him. Even the director of the Morgan Center, Jennifer Sullivan, expressed sympathy for George’s family on her blog for the center. Yes, there are other family members mourning George’s untimely death and his mother’s suicide, but they likely don’t see Elizabeth as a murderer either. There comes a time when the focus needs to change. Start supporting people with disabilities directly. The families need support, I cannot deny that, but the best support for the family is education. Teach parents how to care for their children without controlling them, especially as they reach adulthood.
Many of the services and donations to these families are not directly monetary, but money is the key, everything that is needed and provided has a price tag on it. Most parents of children and adults with disabilities seem to ask, at some point, “when will my son or daughter be independent?”.The answer is that your loved one will be independent when services are properly administered, when the money meant for them is actually in their hands, and when they are treated like human beings and not like burdens on their families and society. Until we have money in our own pockets, we will not be seen as “productive members of society” and our opinions about our own lives will continue to be ignored. When the money intended to help us is controlled by our parents and caregivers, it allows and encourages them to control, abuse, and even murder us. We have dreams of independence beyond removing the “burdens”, but we also have voices that need to be heard. George’s voice can no longer be heard, but mine can and will be, as will those of my colleagues. We are more than a line in a budget, we are human. Focusing on the families is another way to talk about us without us. I urge everyone out there who wants to help people with disabilities to focus on us, to let the help trickle down to our families. Help them by seeing our potential and helping us fulfill it.
If, after reading about George here and reading my own take on this aspect of our lives, you still question the idea that the focus is not on us, you need look no further than Youtube. The videos below are rather lengthy, but they do well to help me show that we as people with disabilities are not the priority in our own lives, even when people and organizations say they are trying to help us. These two videos depict a PowerPoint slideshow that gives statistics relating to the social, economic, and emotional impacts children with disabilities have on their families, such as the costs of care and time spent to care for these children. The parents in attendance are then given the opportunity to respond and tell personal stories. Many of these stories involve the parents explaining how they cannot go out to dinner, or take a family trip to the zoo like a “normal” family. The emphasis is on being a normal family, not on allowing the disabled children to live full happy lives, as it should be. Emphasizing the impact on the families and showing sympathy for parents and caregivers is enabling these families in their effort to control every aspect of their children’s lives, including, in cases like that of George Hodgins, when these lives are to end. Something is blatantly missing from these videos; that is the input from the children who live with the disabilities. If you wish to help us, start by listening to us.
by Clint Berger
Early news stories about George Hodgins’ murder stated the “views” of his mother about the services that were available to help George and people like him, or the alleged lack of them. That statement was later refuted. George Hodgins had been involved in at least one organization that provided him both the help he needed and social interaction in his community. His mother took this away from him, saying that she wanted to find something better for him, but she did not see this through. She instead decided to take his life and her own.
George was affiliated with the Morgan Autism Center in San Jose, California. He was there for schooling and to learn life skills. His mother pulled him out of this program, but did not actively pursue other opportunities for him as she said she would. A representative of the Center stated that they had services available for adults as well as for children. George would have been eligible for adult services at age 22. Instead of letting him continue working with the Morgan Autism Center, Elizabeth Hodgins had something else in mind. George would have learned to be more independent, and he could have made friends and become more active in his community. The opportunity for a full life was stolen from him, and then life itself was stolen as well.
Elizabeth Hodgins used a supposed lack of services for her son as “justification” for murder. To say that this is wrong is a gross understatement. Some of us legitimately do not have services available and we are still alive. Often, the “burden” of raising a disabled child is heavily financial. This is likely one of Elizabeth’s possible motives for George’s murder. We will never find out the true cause of his murder, but it is possible that the monetary costs of caring for George were a factor in her twisted thought process. We will never get the truth, nor will we know the truth of what happened to any of the others whose names were read at the vigils. Since the vigils, more of us have been murdered, and with each of these murders, we all wonder when our voices will be heard.
Money can be tight for families of people with disabilities, but it can be used to control and abuse us; this is a concept and a lifestyle that is very familiar to me. Every day of my life, I get constant reminders of how much it costs for everything from the electric bill to my student loans. I am not on any federal or state assistance, and I am unemployed. I have a caseworker assigned to me who is supposed to be providing services similar to those available to George, but my calls are not returned. My needs are not treated as needs, and I am told I live too far from public transportation to be able to use paratransit. I essentially have nothing available to me right now; and that is why it is so upsetting that someone would lie about their child’s potential to evoke sympathy for themselves. George was working with the Morgan Center, and there are no accounts that justify his mother’s assertion that he was not receiving proper support there.
George’s case brings so many questions for anyone with disabilities. The question at the top of this list is something to the effect of, “How long will they let me live before my life is taken?”, but this is not the only question we have. The next question we all ask ourselves is “how will I be independent?”. We all struggle to be as independent as possible, but many of the government and nonprofit agencies that are established to help people with disabilities are actually geared toward helping their families instead. They are supposed to be helping us, but even they overlook us. George needed help. He needed to remove himself from the family that was supposed to be helping him. Even the director of the Morgan Center, Jennifer Sullivan, expressed sympathy for George’s family on her blog for the center. Yes, there are other family members mourning George’s untimely death and his mother’s suicide, but they likely don’t see Elizabeth as a murderer either. There comes a time when the focus needs to change. Start supporting people with disabilities directly. The families need support, I cannot deny that, but the best support for the family is education. Teach parents how to care for their children without controlling them, especially as they reach adulthood.
Many of the services and donations to these families are not directly monetary, but money is the key, everything that is needed and provided has a price tag on it. Most parents of children and adults with disabilities seem to ask, at some point, “when will my son or daughter be independent?”.The answer is that your loved one will be independent when services are properly administered, when the money meant for them is actually in their hands, and when they are treated like human beings and not like burdens on their families and society. Until we have money in our own pockets, we will not be seen as “productive members of society” and our opinions about our own lives will continue to be ignored. When the money intended to help us is controlled by our parents and caregivers, it allows and encourages them to control, abuse, and even murder us. We have dreams of independence beyond removing the “burdens”, but we also have voices that need to be heard. George’s voice can no longer be heard, but mine can and will be, as will those of my colleagues. We are more than a line in a budget, we are human. Focusing on the families is another way to talk about us without us. I urge everyone out there who wants to help people with disabilities to focus on us, to let the help trickle down to our families. Help them by seeing our potential and helping us fulfill it.
If, after reading about George here and reading my own take on this aspect of our lives, you still question the idea that the focus is not on us, you need look no further than Youtube. The videos below are rather lengthy, but they do well to help me show that we as people with disabilities are not the priority in our own lives, even when people and organizations say they are trying to help us. These two videos depict a PowerPoint slideshow that gives statistics relating to the social, economic, and emotional impacts children with disabilities have on their families, such as the costs of care and time spent to care for these children. The parents in attendance are then given the opportunity to respond and tell personal stories. Many of these stories involve the parents explaining how they cannot go out to dinner, or take a family trip to the zoo like a “normal” family. The emphasis is on being a normal family, not on allowing the disabled children to live full happy lives, as it should be. Emphasizing the impact on the families and showing sympathy for parents and caregivers is enabling these families in their effort to control every aspect of their children’s lives, including, in cases like that of George Hodgins, when these lives are to end. Something is blatantly missing from these videos; that is the input from the children who live with the disabilities. If you wish to help us, start by listening to us.
Thursday, February 28, 2013
Every time I see an Autism Speaks commercial, a little piece of my head explodes
(Originally posted on my tumblr account on April 9, 2012)
I am not autistic, but as a PWD, I see the commercials and the complete avoidance of the people (most often children) who are actually autistic. Most notable is the Tommy Hilfiger ad, where he says “I’m Tommy Hilfiger, and my family is affected by autism.”
He doesn’t even mention which member of his family is autistic like the others do. If they wanted to advertise and actually acknowledge the autistic people, they should let them star in the commercials (or at least give the opportunity to do so). If they completely reversed their strategy, they might be a slightly better organization. Of course, the true solution is to fund research more than these ridiculous commercials, the organization might be more credible that way. What they need to do is get someone like this “nameless” autistic member of Hilfiger’s family to star in the commercial….let them communicate “I am autistic and this is how it affects me: …”(I’m choosing not to be specific here because I don’t want to mislead or offend anyone). Only after they have done that should they even consider having a famous person jump in and tell you who they are and that it’s their child ACTUALLY IN THE COMMERCIAL.
I’m not autistic, as I said, but avoidance of PWDs and the whole “focus on the family” idea just drive me insane. Focusing on families means giving the parents and caregivers the aid that should actually be directly in the hands of the PWDs who need it. Focusing on the families means giving those parents and caregivers the opportunity to control and abuse us. It’s more than opportunity though, it’s somewhere between an opportunity and a command. All disability-related organizations need to realize that donating to the families will not help us, it will kill us. If the money, equipment, or services are in the hands of the PWDs, it will make independence more possible for us. If you donate to organizations like Autism Speaks, all you’re essentially doing is making yourself feel good while perpetuating many negative stereotypes, including the one that says PWDs can’t be independent.
Tuesday, February 26, 2013
Both Teams Win? Not So Much
There's a video going around of a teen with an intellectual disability scoring a basket in his high school basketball game. His name is Mitchell Marcus, and he had served as the team's manager for most of the season. The coach decided to put Mitchell in to play near the end of the team's last game. There are so many problems with this, but it really comes down to one thing, Marcus is just trying to live life to the best of his own ability. He's not here to inspire anyone. The coach, however, does not understand this. In his interview, the coach said he was prepared to lose the game "for his moment." Their team won, but not before a player on the opposing team blatantly passed the ball to Marcus so he could make a basket. That's not basketball. That's not how you play sports. You play to help your own team win.
When Marcus was interviewed, he (apparently) said he was just happy to wear the uniform, even though that came from the mouth of the reporter, not Marcus himself. That should be true of any athlete at any level. If you're not proud to wear the uniform you are wearing, you either stop playing, or in the professional ranks, request a trade. In any case, they called these events "sportsmanship". This is not sportsmanship, this is patronizing. Was Mitchell Marcus happy to play in the game? He was. Was he happy to score the basket? Again, it's fairly obvious he was. Did anybody bother to ask him about HOW he scored that basket? Not at all. Any other player on any other team would be disappointed in themselves missing so many opportunities before that shot, and it's fair to assume that he is no different. That's right, I said it, he is no different. He joined the team, albeit as the manager, to be a member of the team, and probably to make some friends. If he is aware that he would have trouble keeping up with the competition, he wouldn't want to play just to be left in everyone's dust. Would people applaud him for knowing his own limits? I don't think so, but they shouldn't. Nobody asked him about his opponent who blatantly ignored basic basketball strategy. You don't want to pass the ball to an opponent. No exceptions. If he has the basketball knowledge the coach referred to, he would know how patronizing it would be to have these events unfold as they did and to be the unwitting center of it all. I have no doubt that Mitchell Marcus was happy, but I also have no doubt that he was not intending to inspire anyone. He was just trying to be a normal teen, be involved in his favorite sport (even if he couldn't play), and make a few friends, and there is nothing wrong with that. What's "wrong" with the situation is all the TV cameras and the opposing player doing what he did. I wonder whether or not this video would have gone viral if any one factor changed. If Marcus was not disabled, the opposing player is immediately ostracized. If he had made one of the shots he took under normal basketball circumstances, is this "news"?
It's almost as if the news story isn't about Mitchell Marcus at all....until people want to say how inspiring he is. The story is about all the well-intentioned, yet misguided people around him who literally set the stage for him. They all want to show how "nice" they're being to the disabled kid. They want the glory of being kind people, but when disabled people see this, it has the opposite effect. If you want to be kind to anybody who has any sort of disability, don't patronize them like this. Don't act as if "in his mind, the championship is on the line" when in reality it's not, and don't act like that staged basket won this "championship."
There was a similar situation back in 2006 which involved an autistic high school senior named Jason McElwain. His story gained nationwide notoriety when it aired on ESPN, and some things were still taken too far. Some media outlets even labeled him as a "high functioning" autistic which is problematic on another level that I won't discuss here. However, in McElwain's case, he scored all his baskets during the regular course of the game and under normal circumstances. He scored twenty points in four minutes on the court, including 6 three-pointers. A streak like that will reach the media even if the player has no disabilities. He made himself newsworthy by playing well, not by other people setting him up, and not for simply living life to the best of his ability while having a disability.
People without disabilities aren't in the news for daily activities at any age, so why is Mitchell Marcus' story different? It's different because people want to make a big deal about being "nice" to someone who has a disability. It's different because people are wrongfully inspired by things like this. It's different because the majority of people don't see how patronizing it is. Nobody wants to acknowledge that this should not be different at all. That is, nobody without disabilities wants to acknowledge this. The disability community would like to see "news" like this disappear, and I agree with this sentiment. We are not here to inspire anyone except ourselves. We don't want fame and glory for living our lives, and especially not for staged acts of kindness and "sportsmanship". Nobody should be exalted for respecting us. Even the opposing player who threw Marcus the ball said "I was raised to treat others how you want to be treated". This is not how to do that, unless he wants to be inspiring in the way that the disability community abhors. We're not inspirational people, we're just people, and we deserve respect just like everyone else does.
When Marcus was interviewed, he (apparently) said he was just happy to wear the uniform, even though that came from the mouth of the reporter, not Marcus himself. That should be true of any athlete at any level. If you're not proud to wear the uniform you are wearing, you either stop playing, or in the professional ranks, request a trade. In any case, they called these events "sportsmanship". This is not sportsmanship, this is patronizing. Was Mitchell Marcus happy to play in the game? He was. Was he happy to score the basket? Again, it's fairly obvious he was. Did anybody bother to ask him about HOW he scored that basket? Not at all. Any other player on any other team would be disappointed in themselves missing so many opportunities before that shot, and it's fair to assume that he is no different. That's right, I said it, he is no different. He joined the team, albeit as the manager, to be a member of the team, and probably to make some friends. If he is aware that he would have trouble keeping up with the competition, he wouldn't want to play just to be left in everyone's dust. Would people applaud him for knowing his own limits? I don't think so, but they shouldn't. Nobody asked him about his opponent who blatantly ignored basic basketball strategy. You don't want to pass the ball to an opponent. No exceptions. If he has the basketball knowledge the coach referred to, he would know how patronizing it would be to have these events unfold as they did and to be the unwitting center of it all. I have no doubt that Mitchell Marcus was happy, but I also have no doubt that he was not intending to inspire anyone. He was just trying to be a normal teen, be involved in his favorite sport (even if he couldn't play), and make a few friends, and there is nothing wrong with that. What's "wrong" with the situation is all the TV cameras and the opposing player doing what he did. I wonder whether or not this video would have gone viral if any one factor changed. If Marcus was not disabled, the opposing player is immediately ostracized. If he had made one of the shots he took under normal basketball circumstances, is this "news"?
It's almost as if the news story isn't about Mitchell Marcus at all....until people want to say how inspiring he is. The story is about all the well-intentioned, yet misguided people around him who literally set the stage for him. They all want to show how "nice" they're being to the disabled kid. They want the glory of being kind people, but when disabled people see this, it has the opposite effect. If you want to be kind to anybody who has any sort of disability, don't patronize them like this. Don't act as if "in his mind, the championship is on the line" when in reality it's not, and don't act like that staged basket won this "championship."
There was a similar situation back in 2006 which involved an autistic high school senior named Jason McElwain. His story gained nationwide notoriety when it aired on ESPN, and some things were still taken too far. Some media outlets even labeled him as a "high functioning" autistic which is problematic on another level that I won't discuss here. However, in McElwain's case, he scored all his baskets during the regular course of the game and under normal circumstances. He scored twenty points in four minutes on the court, including 6 three-pointers. A streak like that will reach the media even if the player has no disabilities. He made himself newsworthy by playing well, not by other people setting him up, and not for simply living life to the best of his ability while having a disability.
People without disabilities aren't in the news for daily activities at any age, so why is Mitchell Marcus' story different? It's different because people want to make a big deal about being "nice" to someone who has a disability. It's different because people are wrongfully inspired by things like this. It's different because the majority of people don't see how patronizing it is. Nobody wants to acknowledge that this should not be different at all. That is, nobody without disabilities wants to acknowledge this. The disability community would like to see "news" like this disappear, and I agree with this sentiment. We are not here to inspire anyone except ourselves. We don't want fame and glory for living our lives, and especially not for staged acts of kindness and "sportsmanship". Nobody should be exalted for respecting us. Even the opposing player who threw Marcus the ball said "I was raised to treat others how you want to be treated". This is not how to do that, unless he wants to be inspiring in the way that the disability community abhors. We're not inspirational people, we're just people, and we deserve respect just like everyone else does.
Saturday, February 2, 2013
I'm 26, and I'm Tired Too...
Inspired by/response to I'm Tired, by Robert A. Hall, mistakenly attributed to Bill Cosby.
I'm tired too. I have cerebral palsy and chronic pain caused by osteoarthritis. I just received my college degree after eight years of fighting with the university. I've been trying for at least the last four years to find work without so much as a callback for an interview. I'm tired of the cycle of "I can't get work because I have no experience, and I can't get experience because I can't get work." I'm tired of people calling me lazy for it. I'm tired of being denied benefits because people without disabilities tell me that I am not disabled either, especially after living my entire life and having my disability affect me several times a day.
I'm tired of disability benefits being called "benefits". It's not a benefit, it's a necessity for people like me (and I can't get it). I'm tired of people telling me what I can and cannot do, or what I should and should not do. Everybody says "just go get a job", but if it was that easy, none of this would be an issue. I'm tired of hearing that going to college means I'm not disabled. I'm tired of people telling me I'm attempting to take advantage of the system that was put in place for people like me. I'm tired of being denied government help, tired of lawyers telling me I have no case against the government. I'm tired of dealing with employment agencies that only exist because discrimination is constant, even though the government and these agencies will never admit it. I'm tired of getting criticized for not responding to people fast enough, tired of calling people to make sure they are doing their jobs, and tired of being an option for these people when society makes them a necessity for me.
I'm tired of people coming to me to complain about their jobs when I don't have one. I don't mean everyone, if you're being harassed or if working conditions are subpar, those complaints are valid, but "I hate working 9 to 5" will draw nothing more than "give me your job, I need it" out of me. I'm tired of hearing about the bad state of the economy when people like this have jobs. I'm tired of people questioning a work ethic that I haven't even had the opportunity to show. "Make an effort", "be more motivated", "change your attitude", I'm sick of all this. I'm tired of people telling me to contribute to society when I can't even get out on my own.
I'm tired of people telling me when I'm disabled and when I'm not. Maybe things like Medicaid and Social Security payments are called "benefits" because it's become obvious that people take advantage of them. I'm tired of people who reach for their Medicaid card and have an iPhone fall out of their pocket; people seem to think I'd use the payments the same way, but there is zero chance of that. I'm tired of people determining my needs based on my family's income. People need to stop believing I can be treated like a child my whole life, I'm already too old for that.
I'm tired of telling people all this stuff, tired of them not understanding me and THEN criticizing me. I'm tired, but as long as people lump me in with those who deserve the criticism, I can't give up. Now I'm just tired too, I have to stop here and hope the message is clear.
I'm tired too. I have cerebral palsy and chronic pain caused by osteoarthritis. I just received my college degree after eight years of fighting with the university. I've been trying for at least the last four years to find work without so much as a callback for an interview. I'm tired of the cycle of "I can't get work because I have no experience, and I can't get experience because I can't get work." I'm tired of people calling me lazy for it. I'm tired of being denied benefits because people without disabilities tell me that I am not disabled either, especially after living my entire life and having my disability affect me several times a day.
I'm tired of disability benefits being called "benefits". It's not a benefit, it's a necessity for people like me (and I can't get it). I'm tired of people telling me what I can and cannot do, or what I should and should not do. Everybody says "just go get a job", but if it was that easy, none of this would be an issue. I'm tired of hearing that going to college means I'm not disabled. I'm tired of people telling me I'm attempting to take advantage of the system that was put in place for people like me. I'm tired of being denied government help, tired of lawyers telling me I have no case against the government. I'm tired of dealing with employment agencies that only exist because discrimination is constant, even though the government and these agencies will never admit it. I'm tired of getting criticized for not responding to people fast enough, tired of calling people to make sure they are doing their jobs, and tired of being an option for these people when society makes them a necessity for me.
I'm tired of people coming to me to complain about their jobs when I don't have one. I don't mean everyone, if you're being harassed or if working conditions are subpar, those complaints are valid, but "I hate working 9 to 5" will draw nothing more than "give me your job, I need it" out of me. I'm tired of hearing about the bad state of the economy when people like this have jobs. I'm tired of people questioning a work ethic that I haven't even had the opportunity to show. "Make an effort", "be more motivated", "change your attitude", I'm sick of all this. I'm tired of people telling me to contribute to society when I can't even get out on my own.
I'm tired of people telling me when I'm disabled and when I'm not. Maybe things like Medicaid and Social Security payments are called "benefits" because it's become obvious that people take advantage of them. I'm tired of people who reach for their Medicaid card and have an iPhone fall out of their pocket; people seem to think I'd use the payments the same way, but there is zero chance of that. I'm tired of people determining my needs based on my family's income. People need to stop believing I can be treated like a child my whole life, I'm already too old for that.
I'm tired of telling people all this stuff, tired of them not understanding me and THEN criticizing me. I'm tired, but as long as people lump me in with those who deserve the criticism, I can't give up. Now I'm just tired too, I have to stop here and hope the message is clear.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)